Sunday, November 10, 2019
Explore the theme of danger with reference to the extracts from ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢ and ââ¬ËBlood Riverââ¬â¢
Joseph Conradââ¬â¢s ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢ and Tim Butcherââ¬â¢s ââ¬ËBlood Riverââ¬â¢ both explore the theme of danger throughout. This is achieved through Conrad and Butcherââ¬â¢s choice of lexis. The extract from ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢ is taken from chapter eleven. In this extract, Marlow and the rest of the crew of the steamboat are being attacked by the natives of the Congo. The extract from ââ¬ËBlood Riverââ¬â¢ is taken from chapter ten (Bend in the River).In this extract, Butcher describes how a child pickpocket is being attacked by an African mob. Both novels are written in 1st person, but ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢ is fiction, whereas ââ¬ËBlood Riverââ¬â¢ is non-fiction. ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢ was published in 1899 and ââ¬ËBlood Riverââ¬â¢ was published in 2007. The characterisation and narrative methods of the extracts are quite similar. In ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢, Joseph Conrad gives a vivid image of how brutal the natives in the Congo might of been: ââ¬Å"â⬠¦Ã the arrows came in swarms. They might have been poisonedâ⬠¦ â⬠This suggests to the reader that in the Congo, nobody is fully aware of the harm they cause to others or cares about the consequences of their actions as long as it does not affect them and highlights the dangerous nature of the Congo environment. In ââ¬ËBlood Riverââ¬â¢, Tim Butcher gives a vivid image of violent life in the Congo: ââ¬Å"â⬠¦ the mob parted and there was the boy, with his arms twisted behind his backâ⬠.This implies to the reader of how punishment is taken very seriously in the Congo, even when it is a small child being involved and shows just how danger is so common, it comes naturally to the natives of the Congo. The contexts of the extracts are very different to each other. In ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢, Conrad expresses to the reader that when the novel was published in 1899, life in the Congo was qu ite dangerous, so when Marlow is attacked by the natives, while on the steamboat, it came as a surprise for him, although the danger was known to him: ââ¬Å"Arrows by Jove!à We were being shot at! â⬠The use of the word ââ¬ËJoveââ¬â¢ emphasises to the reader that the attack came as a shock for Marlow and highlights the natives and their reaction to foreigners. In ââ¬ËBlood Riverââ¬â¢, Butcher expresses to the reader that at the moment, life in the Congo is different to what it was half a century ago, in the sense that people know more because of travel, news, etc, but the Congo itself has become more brutal and dangerous: ââ¬Å"â⬠¦ I had witnesses numerous times during my stint covering Africaâ⬠¦African mob justice was a terrifying thing. â⬠This implies to the reader that the Congo has changed dramatically over time and that violence is now a common thing to occur. The contextual factors of the two texts are very different as they were written in di fferent times and so the historical backgrounds behind them are different. For example, when ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢ was written, black men were called ââ¬Ëniggersââ¬â¢ and it was thought to be normal to do so back then, but nowadays it would be an offence.In ââ¬ËBlood riverââ¬â¢, Bucher mentions how violent mobs is a thing he has ââ¬Å"witnessed numerous timesâ⬠, but half a century ago was a very rare thing to find in the Congo. The genres of the texts are slightly different. ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢ has a sense of danger and adventure throughout most of the novel: ââ¬Å"The side of his head hit the wheel twice, and the end of what appeared a long cane clattered round and knocked over a little camp-stool. â⬠This suggests to the reader that the novel has elements of danger in it and highlights the dangerous environment of the Congo.ââ¬ËBlood Riverââ¬â¢ also has the same elements of danger imprinted in the novel, but is presented in an informational manner: ââ¬Å"In Swahili, toleka means ââ¬Ëletââ¬â¢s goââ¬â¢, so shouting ââ¬Ëtoleka, tolekaââ¬â¢, I urged my peddler to find the Cohydro offices. â⬠This suggests to the reader that the genre of Butcherââ¬â¢s novel is adventurous, but is laid out in a factual manner that might not be received in the same way as Conradââ¬â¢s exciting manner of expressing danger in the Congo. The social, moral and political agendas of both texts are very different in the sense that the authors treat certain situations different morally.In ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢, Marlow shows that he has morals when he navigates the steamboat to safety and tries to help his fellow crew members: ââ¬Å"He stood before the wide opening, glaring, and I yelled at him to come back, while I straightened the sudden twist out of that steamboat. â⬠This suggests to the reader that Marlow is heroic as he saves many lives during the attack on the steamboat. In ââ¬ËBlood R iverââ¬â¢, however, Tim Bucher seems to abandon his moral standards even though to help people in the Congo is considered pointless: ââ¬Å"I was too preoccupied by my own emergency to worry about the boyââ¬â¢s plight.â⬠This too emphasises the futility of the crisis in the Congo and highlights the dangerous nature of the Congo environment. The features of language change in the extracts are only slight. In ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢, when Marlow and the steamboat crew are attacked by the natives, the language seems archaic to a modern reader in the sense that the language used is no longer in everyday use, but sometimes used to impart an old-fashioned flavour: ââ¬Å"Arrows by Jove!â⬠The use of the word ââ¬ËJoveââ¬â¢ shows the reader that the novel is very old-fashioned as nowadays we would use the expression ââ¬ËOh my God! ââ¬â¢ instead. In ââ¬ËBlood Riverââ¬â¢, Butcher frequently uses modern language when explaining the dangers of the Congo: ââ¬Å"The boyââ¬â¢s mouth was bleeding and the side of his face was squashed flat on the uneven concrete of the forecourt. It was a scene I had witnessed numerous times during my stint covering Africa.â⬠The use of the contemporary word ââ¬Ëstintââ¬â¢, which means ââ¬Ëjobââ¬â¢, suggests to the reader that Butcher is trying to sound more modern when explaining the brutality of the Congo and the dangerous nature of the Congo environment, and the casualness of the word highlights that violence is quite commonplace in the Congo. It could also suggest that Butcher is at ease when discussing African violence as he has come across so much of it in the past. In conclusion, both extracts of ââ¬ËHeart of Darknessââ¬â¢ and ââ¬ËBlood Riverââ¬â¢ explore the theme of danger in similar ways, but have different effects on the readers.For example, Conrad fictional writing, although based on true events, could be seen by the reader as just fiction and dangerous aspect s of the novel might not be as taken across as important as Butcherââ¬â¢s real expedition of the Congo and the dangers it contains. Both Conrad and Butcher have shown their own views of the Congo very carefully within the texts, to an extent where the reader can see the views of both authors as their own, and allowing them to see how dangerous the Congo environment really is.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.